FROM OUR FAMILY TO YOURS

• CUSTOM CAKES • ARTISAN PIES PASTRIES • COOKIES •

Order Here

Place your order online by November 17th, or come in to see us at the shop.

We would love to see you!

Pickup for Pies is

Tuesday

November 24th

Celebrate Thanksgiving with a delicious selection of scratch-made pies for your holiday table! Choose from classic apple and pumpkin, plus brown butter pecan, mixed berry crumble, blueberry, and key lime. Thanksgiving pre-orders are open on October 17th through November 17th with pick-up on Tuesday November 24th. Order early and share a little Shugah Hill sweetness with family and friends. We’re grateful to be part of your holiday traditions!

OUR SWEET PROMISE

We’re best friends who share a passion for baked-from-scratch goodness and all things buttercream! We promise that our distinctively different desserts will delight you. Everything we bake is made on-site with fresh ingredients from our own family recipes.

If you would like to order a Custom Cake, please call us at 781-924-5493. Our ability to accept custom orders is dependant on demand, therefore we highly recommend placing your order early. Thank you for your understanding.

With fall baking upon us, and our anniversary celebration around the corner, we wanted to talk about our process as a scratch bakery. We love baking with all natural ingredients, and never take shortcuts with premade muffin and cake mixes, frozen cookies, commercially prepared fillers, or frozen pie crusts. We hand roll every pie crust for every pie we sell - and truly believe this gives our customers the highest quality product. We look forward to baking for your family this holiday season, which includes rolling out over a thousand pies! Thank you for your support ❤️ Thanksgiving pre-orders open 10/20.

Embrace the flavors of fall with our Apple Pear Cranberry Pie 🥧 . #applepie #homemadepie #fallflavors #hanoverma #southshorema #bostonfood #bostonfoodies

💍Happy one year anniversary to @rachelblauner and @brettmiller8419 ❤️❤️❤️ We love you two!

It’s September 1st and you know what that means? It’s officially acceptable to indulge in fall flavors ✨ Here is our Pumpkin Spice latte paired perfectly with our Pumpkin Muffin topped with cream cheese frosting. #pumpkinspice #pumpkinseason #bakery #southshorema #hanoverma

Our favorite key lime pies restocked and ready to go! They sell out quickly - so pop on by. Often imitated, never duplicated - treat yourself to this Shugah Hill original. They be bussin.

Chocolate peanut butter cake available - limited quantities. Very chocolately. Very peanuty. Not like those other girls. . Place your custom cake orders today! . #chocolatepeanutbutter #cakedecorating #peanutbutter #chocolate #yum #bakery

Don’t sleep on our breakfast sandwiches! Available every weekend 😋

✨Vanilla cake with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream. Very mindful, not too much. . Stop by the bakery to try for yourself!. . #cakedecorating #verymindful #treatyourself #hanoverma #southshorema #bostonfood

We’re back from vacation, open and ready for our valued customers ❤️

The Peppermint Twist cast and crew celebrating a successful shoot with this massive cake! ❤️ we love you ❤️ See you at the movies! @the_peppermint_twist

Look at these cutie pie cupcakes our bakers Jess and Bailey made today ❤️ limited supplies and selling fast! Come get you some! . #cupcakes #icecream #bakery #icecreamcone #yummy #scrummy #hanoverma #southshorema

Chocolate Cake - three layers of rich chocolate cake made with a hint of espresso, covered with chocolate buttercream and rich chocolate ganache. Chocolate overload, but in the best way possible! . FYI we will be closed next week to give our staff a much needed vacation! ✨ . #chocolatecake #ganache #espresso #bakery #cafe #bostonfood #southahorefood #hanoverma